CHARMM

Table Of Contents

Previous topic

Analysis Commands

Next topic

Adaptive Umbrella Sampling Module

This Page

Analytical Continuum Solvent (ACS) Potential

Purpose: calculate solvation free energy and forces based on a continuum description of the solvent, in particular the analytical continuum electrostatics (ACE) potential.

Please report problems to Michael Schaefer at schaefer@piaf.u-strasbg.fr

Warning

The module is still being developed and may change in the future.

Warning

Note on ACE2: the version 2 of ACE as of Jan 2002 is not yet fully parameterized; it yields reasonably stably MD trajectories of native proteins when using param19 (united atom parameters), but is unreliable with all-hydrogen parameters.

REFERENCES:

    1. Schaefer & M. Karplus (1996) J. Phys. Chem. 100, 1578-1599.
    1. Schaefer, C. Bartels & M. Karplus (1998) J. Mol. Biol. 284, 835-847.
    1. Calimet, M. Schaefer & T. Simonson, (2001) Proteins 45, 144-158
  • M. Schaefer, C. Bartels, F. Leclerc& M. Karplus (2001), J. Comp. Chem. 22, 1857-1879.

Syntax

Syntax: The ACE specifications can be specified any time the nbond
        specification parser is invoked, e.g.,
     ENERgy [other-spec] [ace-spec]

ace-spec::=
        [ ACE ] [ IEPS real ] [ SEPS real ] [ ALPHa real ]
        [ SIGMa real ] [ IDEAl | CURRent ] [FVSCaling real]
        [ ACE2 [ MXBSolv real ] [TBSOlv real ] [ TBSHydrogens real ]]

Defaults

The defaults for the ACE potential are:

IEPS 1.0
SEPS 80.0
ALPHa 1.3
SIGMa 0.0
IDEAl true
FVSCa 1.0

The additional defaults for the ACE2 potential are:

MXBSo 14.0
TBSOl 8.4
TBSHy 3.85

In the current implementation, ACE should be used with united atom parameters, ALPHa set equal to 1.3, the standard PARAM19 parameter file param19.inp and Voronoi volumes as given in acepar19.inp (toppar and test/data).

Introduction

The analytical continuum solvent (ACS) potential is introduced to perform molecular dynamics/minimization calculations with a continuum approximation of the solvent.

Two solvent contributions to the effective (free) energy of a solute are included: the electrostatic solvation free energy, and the non-polar (i.e., non-electrostatic) solvation free energy. The first (electrostatic) contribution (G_el) is calculated using an analytical approximation to the solution of the Poisson-equation called ACE (from: analytical continuum electrostatics). The non-polar solvation free energy (G_np) is approximated by a pairwise potential which yields results that are very similar to the well-known surface area approximations of the hydrophobic (solvation) energy (e.g., Wesson and Eisenberg, Prot. Sci. 1 (1992), 227–235; see the ASP potential in CHARMM).

Restriction

The ACE solvation potential has to be used together with no cutoff or with atom based switching.

Compatibility

  1. ACE can be used with BLOCK (but: the diagonal elements of the BLOCK matrix MUST NOT be zero).
  2. ACE can be used with fixing atoms (CONS FIX); the resulting energy and forces are an approximation, because all the interaction-dielectric terms of the potential (eq (47) in Schaefer & Karplus, JPC 100 (1996), 1578) which involve two fixed atoms are neglected, despite the fact that they exist and that they are not invariant!

Meaning of the ACE parameters

  1. IEPS

    Dielectric constant for the space occupied by the atoms that are treated explicitly, e.g., the space occupied by the protein.

  2. SEPS

    Dielectric constant for the space occupied by the solvent that is treated as a continuum (i.e., the complement of the space occupied by the protein).

  3. ALPHa

    The volumes occupied by individual (protein) atoms are described by Gaussian density distributions. The factor ALPHa controls the width of these Gaussians. The net volume of the individual atom Gaussian distributions is defined in the volume table in the parameter file acepar19.inp. The volumes in the acepar19.inp file are expected to work best for an ALPHa of 1.3.

  4. SIGMa

    The ACE solvation potential includes a hydrophobic contribution which is roughly proportional to the solvent accessible surface area. The factor SIGMa scales the hydrophobic contribution. For peptides with about 10-15 residues, a SIGMa factor of 3.0 results in hydrophobic contributions that are approximately equal to the solvent accessible surface area multiplied by 8 cal/(mol*A*A).

  1. IDEAl | CURRent

    As of c29a2, the ACE potential considers the distances between atoms in the nonbonded exclusion list as invariant. This is consistent with the assumption that the forces involving these atoms are governed by the internal energy terms (bond, angle, and some 1-4 atom pairs in aromatic ring systems). Note that solvation forces still apply to pairs of these atoms, considered as a polar group.

    With the IDEAl option (default), ACE calculates the nonbonded exclusion list distances from ideal bond length and angles where possible; the distances for 1-4 atom pairs in the exclusion list are calculated from the current atom positions at the first ACE energy call. With the CURRent option, all the distances between atoms in the nonbonded exlusion list are calculated from the current coordinates of the atoms. These distances are considered invariant for all subsequent energy calls, during minimization and dynamics. Recalculation of the nb-exclusion list atom pair distance is enforced only when toggling IDEAl on/off, fixing/unfixing atoms, or a change of the psf (e.g., REPLica).

  1. FVSCal

    One major problem with ACE1 (and gneralized Born methods in general) is the overestimation of the desolvation by the pairwise de-screening function ESELFIK (see ace.src). One way to reduce the impact of this systematic error is to reduce the volume that is assigned to the atoms by a constant factor FVSCal < 1 as proposed in Calimet et al., Proteins 45 (2001), 144-158. The default value for FVSCal is 1.0, though a value of 0.9 appears reasonable in conjunction with param19 and volumes in acepar19, using the ACE1 potential (work in progress). Note that the modified treatment of the self energy (de-screening) potential in ACE2 is aimed at fixing the overestimation problem of ESELFIK such that the re-scaling of volumes becomes obsolete (work in progress).

  1. ACE2

    The ACE2 keyword implies ACE (no need to specify both). It invokes a modified treatment of the Born solvation radii which are limited by un upper bound — MXBSolv (see below). This takes account of the overestimation of the desolvation of charges by the pairwise de-screening potential in ACE1.

  1. MXBSolv

    The Born solvation radii of all atoms (charges) are limited by the upper bound parameter MXBSolv (default 14.0 Angstrom).

  1. TBSOl

    In the ACE2 potential, the conventional conversion of the atomic solvation to the Born solvation radii is applied until a Born radius of TBSOlv is obtained (“turning point”). After that, atomic solvation energies (i.e., the de-solvation) is converted in a way that prevents the Born solvation radii from exceeding the imposed maximum. Details will be given in an upcoming publication.

  1. TBSHyd

    This parameter has the same meaning as TBSOl, but applies to hydrogens, which are most susceptible to an overestimation of the desolvation by neighboring atoms (volumes). The smaller the TBSOl and TBSHyd, the more the over-desceening is counter- acted (parametrization in progress).

Examples

To set up simulations/minimizations with the ACE solvation potential, read the standard CHARMM topology and parameter files and the corresponding ACE parameter file using

read ACEParameters card unit IUN

e.g., the file acepar19.inp with param19 parameters. The following energy call is expected to be adequate for most cases, including proteins:

ENERgy ATOM ACE2 IEPS 1.0 SEPS 80.0 ALPHa 1.3 SIGMa 2.5 SWITch -
       VDIS VSWI CUTNB 13.0 CTONNB 8.0 CTOFNB 12.0

When you run molecular dynamics or minimization with ACE, you get two more lines in the log file printout with energy terms, e.g.,

DYNA DYN: Step         Time      TOTEner        TOTKe       ENERgy  TEMPerature
DYNA PROP:             GRMS      HFCTote        HFCKe       EHFCor        VIRKe
DYNA INTERN:          BONDs       ANGLes       UREY-b    DIHEdrals    IMPRopers
DYNA EXTERN:        VDWaals         ELEC       HBONds          ASP         USER
DYNA PRESS:            VIRE         VIRI       PRESSE       PRESSI       VOLUme
DYNA ACE1:      HYDRophobic         SELF    SCREENing      COULomb
DYNA ACE2:        SOLVation  INTERaction
 ----------       ---------    ---------    ---------    ---------    ---------
DYNA>        0      0.00000  -3423.29671      0.00000  -3423.29671      0.00000
DYNA PROP>          4.45310  -3423.12228      0.52327      0.17442   -532.70519
DYNA INTERN>        6.58717     60.43092      0.00000     56.00750      7.32144
DYNA EXTERN>     -380.26218  -3173.38156      0.00000      0.00000      0.00000
DYNA PRESS>         0.00000    355.13679      0.00000      0.00000      0.00000
DYNA   ACE1>      109.04469  -3829.20991   2750.59427  -2203.81062
DYNA   ACE2>    -1078.61564    546.78365
 ----------       ---------    ---------    ---------    ---------    ---------

and the same during minimization (MINI...) or after an energy calculation (ENER...).

The terms in lines with ACE1 and ACE2 are:

HYDRophobic Hydrophobic potential, equivalent to a surface based solvation term proportional to the sigma input parameter;
SELF Self contribution to electrostatic solvation free energy, Delta-E_self, first term of eq(8) (i.e., sum over all atomic solvation energies, Delta-E_self_i, eq(28));
SCREENing Interaction contribution to electrostatic solvation free energy, i.e., screening of Coulomb interactions, eq(38) (sum over all atom pairs, including bonded and 1-3 atom pairs!);
COULomb Coulomb energy with constant dielectric of EPSI (sum over all atom pairs for the first term in eq(36) – excluding bonded and 1-3 atom pairs, and 1-4 atom pair contributions scaled with E14FAC);
SOLVation Electrostatic (!) solvation free energy, sum of SELF and SCREENing;
INTERaction Electrostatic interaction, sum of SCREENing and COULomb (eq(36), but taking account of the bonded, 1-3, and 1-4 exclusion in the Coulomb term, see above).

The term “ELEC” in line “DYNA EXTERN>...” is the total electrostatic energy:

ELEC: Sum of SELF, SCREENing, COULomb.

Equation numbers refer to Schaefer & Karplus, J. Phys. Chem. 100 (1996), 1578.

See also: test cases c27test/ace1.inp and c29test/ace_v2.inp.